Old-fashioned? or suprisingly engaging?

Are Cuisenaire rods old-fashioned in an English class? Or does their simplicity make the functional vocabulary (ie the grammar) stand out?

At the moment in this blog, I’m reporting on the workshop I led at IATEFL 2025 in Edinburgh: ‘Teaching speaking as a skill: innovative ways of correcting!

I showed a series of short films from real classes, and the fifty or so participants discussed what we’d watched.

I blogged about the second film the other day, but I’m writing about it again to day because there’s more to be reported from the discussion. One of the participants felt very strongly that it wasn’t appropriate for a teacher to use old-fashioned things like Cuisenaire rods in this day and age. I guess the word ‘rod’ was felt to be not particularly useful and perhaps the work not particularly communicative or engaging. Others noted that ‘rod ‘could be anything …

My take on this is: watch the film and look at the students. Are they engaged? Are they interested in what they are doing? Are they working hard? Do you think they’re learning? Doesn’t the simplicity of the objects throw into focus the functional vocabulary ie that which carries the grammar of English?

One thought on “Old-fashioned? or suprisingly engaging?”

  1. Why do people play soccer or cricket or rugby? I mean, how passé! How old-fashioned! And maths is thousands of years old ! I mean, what do teachers have in MIND when they force young people to learn these things?
    Rods are very recent, compared to these. They are 20th century. That’s modern by most education standards.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *