My trip to Catalonia

This blog entry illustrates what can be achieved in about a year and a half of learning Catalan from scratch using the Silent Way.

This video extract comes from an English lesson I gave to a group of colleagues from Catalonia. I started the lesson by telling them something in Catalan about my plans. It’s not something I would normally do – our lessons are about them expressing themselves and their lives in English, so usually I avoid taking up time speaking.

On this occasion I made an exception because:

  • I needed to be absolutely certain that everyone had understood the practical message – ie that our regular weekly lesson was cancelled for the following Thursday. And I thought a good way to do that would be to tell them in Catalan, and then make sure they’d understood by getting them to explain what I’d just said in English. I hadn’t prepared a ‘speech’; I just relied on the Catalan skills I’ve developed so far through our Catalan course.
  • I could have explained in English, but that would have made their task a lot easier – they’d have already heard these ideas expressed in English. So the good memorisers in the group could simply repeat back the words and phrases I’d used. I didn’t want them copying – I wanted them to create their own English sentences.

The lesson then proceeded as normal – the students generated sentences about the situation and posed questions they were curious about. We worked on each of these sentences until they were correct and natural and well-pronounced and then the students practised saying them. I answered their questions in Catalan. And then they explained the new information about the situation in English.

Once their sentences had been well-practised orally they wrote down most of them, getting a little more practice in the process. Here’s the record of the sentences from the lesson.

What can be achieved if you focus on quality

Here’s the video extract of me talking in Catalan which started off this English lesson. It illustrates what can be achieved in about a year and a half of learning a foreign language starting from scratch.

Three of us have been following this Catalan course together and we’ve had 65 hours of lessons, all online, using the Silent Way. All of us show the same degree of spontaneity and ease in speaking the language. (For another example, check out this blog entry from last week.)

For me the reason this approach has worked so well is that:

  • we’ve focused on quality all the way through – this means that students develop inner certainty about the language and this frees them to express themselves orally with confidence
  • we’ve practised saying every sentence several times – practice like this means that students’ muscles and mouths and minds get used to assembling their sentences and ‘getting them out’ with ease

It’s quite straightforward: skills have to be practised to become easy and fluent, but it only makes sense to automatise things that are correct.

Accuracy and fluency and expressiveness go together

Accuracy and fluency are often seen as in some kind of opposition. But it doesn’t have to be like that. Check out this video to see the progress that students can make if you know how to help them.

Accuracy and fluency are often seen as in some kind of opposition. But it doesn’t have to be like that. This video illustrates that throughout a course you can work on the accuracy of every sentence and nevertheless not stifle students’ confidence, nor their ability to speak spontaneously to express their thoughts.

Indeed by focusing on accuracy in this way, we help students to develop precisely the kind of inner certainty that enables them to speak with ease.

Of course, teachers need to know how to work this way – how to correct in a way that grows students’ inner criteria for the language, and then make sure students practice each sentence properly. And this requires a very different approach from the usual rules, exercises and memorisation approach.

Check out this video extract from one of our Catalan lessons. This short extract comes from after we’d had 65 hours of teaching using the Silent way. In every lesson of our course, right from the start, our teachers have worked on every sentence following these three simple steps:

  • one of us tries to say something
  • straight away our teachers give us feedback and guidance and we work on the sentence until every aspect is correct: grammar, word choice and pronunciation
  • once it’s correct we practise saying it a few times until it begins to be easier to get out of our mouths

This means over the last year and a half we’ve developed an intutive feel for much of the grammar of the language, we’ve learned a reasonable amount of everyday vocabulary and we’ve practised a lot of speaking.

The results speak for themselves we really can ‘have our cake and eat it’ – fast progress, a high degree of accuracy and plenty of confidence in speaking a foreign language. And we can enjoy ourselves whilst doing it.

A trip to St Andrews

Read this post to see a new tool to help students practise in class in action … and, at the same time, find out how much progress we’ve made in learning to speak Catalan

This post reports on a new tool I’ve been using in my language classes. It’s designed for courses based on the ‘speaking first’ principle. It is intended for students who have learned enough of a language to join Class Conversations.

The tool helps them:

  • consolidate the sentences and stories they create, orally, in their lessons
  • make their first steps in reading and writing and get feedback and help on these from their teachers.

The tool adapts techniques that Silent Way teachers have used for many purposes for many years, and adapts them for the above goals and the online environment that the shared white board ‘Miro’ offers.

Watch this video containing extracts from a recent Catalan lesson to see the tool in action.

Why does it work?

The work always starts from stories the students themselves create, orally, in the lesson. This means that:

  • the sentences aren’t preset or text book material and they express whatever the student themselves wanted to say
  • the sentences are always correct – the teacher and the students have worked together to achieve that. Practising incorrect sentences would be a colossal waste of time and energy.

So these sentences are definitely worth practising. And the students will get far more long-term benefit out of their time in class if the learning is consolidated and their speaking made more fluid.

This simply means that students need say these sentences again in the same form. Most people find this hard – they tend to change, paraphrase or rework their sentences – that’s how language normally works. But that’s exactly what we don’t want for this phase of their learning. (Of course, once the learning is stabilised they or we can try out all kinds of variations. But these variations themselves also then need to be practiced.)

As you can see from the video, the tool provides a little support to make that practice easier, more consistent and fun.

P.S.

Just in case you didn’t notice it when you watched the video, watch it again and register how much progress we’ve made in Catalan in just a little over 50 hours. We started from scratch knowing nothing about a year ago, and this video shows just how far we’ve got. Check out the earlier entries on this blog (here) if you want to find out how we did it.

El Poble

Read this article to find out how we’ve been using a simple floor plan of a town to help students express themselves creatively in a foreign language

This plan provides a useful focus for a language class at intermediate level. We used it with our classes at school in Catalonia a few weeks ago. One of the great things about this is that you can work at whatever level the particular class can handle. Things like:

  • ‘What’s in this town?’ ‘There is a river and a park in this town’
  • ‘Where is the town hall?’
  • ‘Jaume goes out of his house, turns right, crosses the zebra crossing, goes through the square in front of the town hall etc’
  • ‘The streets are dangerous, so you have to cross using the zebra crossings’
  • ‘There isn’t a school in this town so the children have to take the bus every morning’
  • ‘Usually Jaume goes to work in the factory on foot, but if it’s raining he takes the bus’

The town plan has advantages over a static picture, because, simply by moving things around on the plan, the meaning of what’s being said can be made clear. What’s more students can be active by illustrating the actions on the board, by giving instructions, and by asking questions of each other.

Using the plan in the classroom

We used ‘El Poble’ (the town) in our classroom at school in Catalonia a few weeks back producing some impressive language.

Here’s an example led by one of the students:

“Soc en el bar. Estic pensant que fer al llarg del matí. Aniré al banc per treure diners, i després aniré a l’Ajuntament per fer els documents, i després tornaré a casa.”

Q: Perquè treuràs diners?
A: Per comprar un cotxe nou
Q: On aniràs amb cotxe nou?
A: Aniré a Xina

“I’m at the bar. I’m thinking about what to do all morning. I’m going to the bank to get some money, and then I’m going to the city hall to get the paperwork done, and then I’m going home.”

Q: Why are you going to get some money?
A: To buy a new car
Q: Where are you going to go with the new car?
A: I’m going to China

This conversation then continued with everyone else in the class telling us where they would go with a new car …

Using the plan online

We’ve also used the plan online in our lessons. Watch the video to see how we took the conversation in our own completely different direction.

In fact what we did in this example built directly on the work we’ve been doing recently with the Catalan verb system – our conversation naturally got us to tell a story ranging across a series of different tenses and verb forms.

Conclusion

This is an example of how you can use really simple tools like this to help students expand their range to express themselves better in a language – it’s completely different from exercises and filling in the blanks and learning grammar.

Working on the Catalan verb system

Read this post to find out how we’re developing a visual model to help students get to grips with the Catalan verb system

Recently we’ve been developing tools to help teach the verb system of Catalan. We want students to develop an intuitive sense for:

  • how verbs conjugate
  • the different tenses

At the moment we’re experimenting with this ‘arrow’ model to work on the tenses (we’ve already developed a verbs ‘wheel‘ to work on conjugation). Each of the rods represents one of the tenses, and their arrangement symbolises something about how they relate to each other and to the passage of time. It’s not a grammarian’s or a linguist’s description of the language. It’s a teaching tool, to help students develop, intuitively, a sense for how the different tenses are used, their relationships and their differences.

The idea is to enable students to tie together the tenses and their usage without grammatical terminology and explanations. Apart from anything else this avoids students intellectualising about the language – which tends to hinder the development of their speaking. Because the model is visual, we and our students can simply point on the model when we want to analyse a sentence a student has said, or when we need to give feedback or when a student needs a hint about where to start.

For example, in this model the green rod in the middle on the dotted ‘ara’ (now) line represents the so-called ‘present’ tense, the blue one on the right the ‘future’ tense and the yellow one at the top, the infinitive.

As with everything else in this Catalan project, we’re developing this tool by trial and error: by using it, seeing what works well and what doesn’t, and adapting as we go.

In this video you’ll see us using this model in a recent lesson.

For anyone who’s interested, similar models have been developed for English, French and for Spanish. Of course, each of these models are rather different, reflecting each language’s unique character.

A morning routine: working on the verb system

A key part of our Catalan project has been building classroom materials to teach students to speak the language. This post shows us beginning to work on tools to teach the verb system.

We’d been discussing how to help students master the Catalan verb system, and how we could devise classroom materials to help with this. In the film below, you’ll see us trying out a first draft of a new chart designed by our two Catalan teachers to help teach verb conjugations.

We were looking for something that:

  • minimizes the need for memorisation. Memorisation saps students’ energy—something they need an abundance of to learn well. What’s more, even when students work hard at memorising things like verb endings, the results are usually unreliable
  • avoids intellectualisation, which all too often leads to ‘knowledge about’ the language rather than the ‘know how’ to speak
  • helps students uncover the patterns in the language, and helps them to see that the system isn’t endless—there are always only a limited number of possibilities to choose from
  • would be easy to use in the classroom to introduce new verbs and new forms, and to give students immediate feedback
  • would support students’ practise in class so that using the verbs would gradually become easier, more fluent and more accurate.

A verb conjugation chart

The teachers built on work done over the years for other languages, and, of course, their knowledge of Catalan. And they continued our use of ‘rapid prototyping’ when developing materials—create something, try it out quickly, consider how it worked and then try again.

The first sketch of the chart our teachers created is above in this blog post and the film below shows extracts from a couple of lessons where we tried it out:

When to introduce this kind of chart?

This kind of work needs to come at the right time in a course. We’d already had a fair amount of experience of the language, and in our previous lessons we’d worked with these verbs, albeit solely in the third person. That gave us a solid stock of experience speaking the language and of using verbs to build on. It wouldn’t be wise to try to use a chart like this with students with much less experience of the language and of this way of learning than we already had.

We took it step by step. In the first lesson illustrated in this film we started with talking in the 1st person about a morning routine. And then in the subsequent lesson we extended that until we were using 1st, 2nd and 3rd persons.

This slow build up is important: students need practice and time to assimilate every new stage properly. The benefit of this step-by-step approach shows in the second lesson in the video: we were noticeably less hesitant and much more fluent with these new verb forms even after just one lesson.

It’s a teaching tool, not a reference work

The charts we’re aiming to build are teaching tools, designed for use in the classroom. We’re not creating reference works, although once students have got used to this kind of chart they often like to take copies home to jog their minds when they practise.

There’s more work to be done, but its a good start.

Teaching Catalan in school using the Silent Way

You can teach students to speak a foreign language without text books, work sheets, exercises, reading or note taking. Watch this film to see us doing exactly that with students recently arrived in Catalonia.

Our Catalan project started in July 2025 with two intertwined goals:

  • we two students wanted to learn to speak Catalan, and
  • our teachers wanted to develop better ways to teach Catalan to the students in their school

These goals were intertwined by design: the teachers would develop their skills using the Silent Way by teaching us; and, in parallel using ‘trial and error’, we would develop the materials needed to teach efficiently.

We students were later joined by two colleagues who also wanted to learn the language. I’ve reported on the first goal in past entries on this blog, but now I’m reporting on the second—applying the approach and what we had developed in school.

Visiting the school

I visited the school in February 2026 to learn more about the students and what they were finding difficult about the language; to offer any advice I could about how to help students with these difficulties; and to discuss face-to-face with the teachers the next steps for our project.

The students come from around the world and have been living in Catalonia for various amounts of time, some shorter, some longer. They need to work on their Catalan so they can participate in normal school and social life. They come to these Catalan language classes for various amounts of time each week depending on each student’s circumstances. The teachers have been using the Silent Way with these students since October 2025.

On the Monday of my visit one of the teachers and I taught the classes together. I provided the structure of the lessons and the teacher provided the Catalan – words, grammar, pronunciation, stress. Some parts of the lessons were filmed and we’ve made this short film documenting the work.

The sound-colour chart

Since October the teachers have been using the sound-colour chart in all their lessons to introduce new words and work on pronunciation. This chart is designed to give a precise way to refer to the sounds of a language in the classroom without using letters. Letters are often ambiguous, unhelpful for students from different linguistic backgrounds and a barrier for non-readers. The chart also gives a quick, precise way to give students feedback on their pronunciation by simply pointing to the coloured rectangles on the chart.

The teachers and I had built the chart through trial and error in our online lessons since July 2025. And since they’d been working with it since October 2025, the students were familiar with it.

Speaking is the priority

The spoken language is our priority, so we don’t use text books or worksheets or reading in our classes. And the students don’t take notes. Our goal is that they develop the skills to speak spontaneously and well. For that they need to store the language in their minds, not on paper.

The students spoke and got immediate feedback for the whole of the lessons illustrated in the film. There was no ‘teacher talk’ or explanations. Any talking that we teachers did, was minimal: just what was needed to direct and guide the activities.

The words on the board

In the film you’ll see various words written on the board. We introduced new words to the students using the sound-colour chart, and then worked on that word’s stress. This meant that the students first met these words by saying them and working on their pronunciation.

Only once the students could say them well, were the written forms shown. Either we, the teachers, or one of the students wrote them on the board. That meant we had something to point to if we needed to refer to them, and it eliminated any pressure on students to try to memorise these words. We wanted them to store this everyday vocabulary in their minds for the long term, by use, familiarity and practice.

Responsive teaching

Because the students were speaking all the time, we, the teachers, always knew what they could do well and where they needed more help or more practice. In other words we had the information to judge, moment-by-moment, whether to move on or whether to consolidate.

And because the lesson wasn’t pre-planned in detail or text book-based, it was easy to spontaneously adjust, vary or replay some of the action. And, if we judged the students were ready, to push them one step forward.

Feedback on students’ attempts

We gave feedback sentence by sentence, either by gesture or by pointing at a word or rectangle on the sound-colour chart. This meant students could immediately correct what they said and practise it. It also meant that everyone else could see and hear each mistake and its correction—so they could also learn from that process.

There are a couple of things in how we gave feedback that we could improve for the future:

  • the first is practical. The room was cramped and with two of us working together sometimes we obscured some of the students’ view of the board.
  • the second is a bit more subtle. We might have been over-helpful sometimes—perhaps partly because I was working with these students for the first time. As a general rule it’s better to give less help, provided the students stand a chance of fixing the problem themselves: the less we do, the more they do. And the more they do, the more likely that the learning will stick for the long term.

We’ve tested the approach … but there is more to do

As you can see from the entries about Catalan in this blog to date, our specific application of the Silent Way approach to teaching Catalan has been tested with two groups of students in two different contexts: a group of adult beginners in online lessons since July 2025 and groups of immigrant teenagers at school since October 2025.

But there is more to do: our next steps will tackle how best to work with students on the Catalan verb system. This was the main issue we teachers discussed when I visited the school and we came up with some promising ideas which we are developing and testing over the coming weeks and months.

Overall

The film illustrates a series of lessons where students were talking Catalan virtually the whole time, were enjoying themselves, and were learning at the same time. This way of working can be applied to any language.

The film demonstrates an important fact: you can create courses to teach students to speak a foreign language without text books, work sheets, exercises, readings or note taking.

Indeed, I’d make a stronger claim: we were able to get all the students speaking like this because we’d dispensed with all this language class paraphernalia.

A morning routine

Find out how, as we moved the characters around on the floor plan of a house, we were stimulated to work on the language needed to describe someone’s normal morning routine but … then we met an unexpected situation.

Below there’s a video extract from our most recent Catalan lesson. We’d been talking about Jaume and Maria’s normal morning routine and moving the characters around on this floor plan of their house as the different events unfolded.

The beauty of moving the characters around a simple plan like this is:

  • everyone knows what’s happening without explanation or translation
  • events can be replayed as often as needed for the students to practise
  • the sequence of events can be readily changed or new activities or new language added as students’ skills develop
  • unlike text book examples, what happens isn’t pre-set, and students as well as teachers can take over control of the narrative
  • during the course of an hour’s lesson a lot of language can be generated, worked on and practised

In fact, as you’ll see in this video extract, as the action played out one of the students ended up with a situation that surprised everyone. And that led to an opportunity for the teachers to introduce some new aspects of the language that we’d not met before.

The teachers used the sound-colour chart and the word charts to provide the new language we students needed to tell the story properly. Pointing on the sound-colour chart is an efficient way of giving students the pronunciation of new words whilst avoiding the ambiguities and confusion that writing and spelling systems often cause. It forces students to pay attention to the sounds of the words and their sequence and to hold them in their minds: this extra effort makes it more likely that they will be retained.

This lesson was also unusual in that we were joined for the first time in a live lesson by Nicoleta Surdu, who has been learning Catalan by following the full videos of our lessons and practising by herself. As you can see, she’s learnt a lot of Catalan this way and was able to fully participate in the class! Congratulations, Nicoleta: an impressive achievement.

Using contrasts to work on verb tenses

In the latest update from our Catalan project, we’re using the contrast between what someone ‘normally does’ and what they ‘did today’ to explore how Catalan uses verbs in different tenses.

We’re at level 3 in the Silent Way progression framework: we’ve got a grounding in the sounds, rhythms and melodies of Catalan and the functional vocabulary. And now we’re adding everyday vocabulary and working on how the language expresses time.

In our most recent lessons we’ve been exploring talking about a character’s typical day using images like these.

These images are easily manipulated on screen so we can get endless, varied practice very easily.  Because we are working with pictures, the sequence of events is always clear. Also the sentences we create never need to be written down.  The scenarios can be made as short and simple as we want or as long and elaborate as we can cope with.  

It’s a great way to introduce this everyday vocabulary, the various verb forms needed, and you can eliminate distractions. Students can only really be present to one thing at a time and we want them to be the focussed on that. So:

  • we used a situation with just a single character so that we only needed the third person – trying to deal with the whole range of conjugations at once would be too much at this stage.
  • we kept as much of the situation as possible constant while we explored the contrast between the characters ‘normal’ day and what specifically they had done ‘today’ before our class

Here’s a short video showing some extracts from our lesson:

During the lesson we students generated some thirty or so sentences which described aspects of the situation, all worked on until they were correct and then practised until they started to become easy to say. This is efficient – just two minutes per example sentence – and it gave us lots of experience of both the ‘mechanics’ of how the verbs work – some endings, auxiliaries, word order, associated pronouns, reflexivity etc – and the significance or types of situations these forms are associated with.

So, now our minds have this stock of reliable well-mastered material to work on and to generalise from. And we can rely on sleep to do the next stage of consolidating this and integrating it with the rest of our Catalan. And that will give us a solid base to work from for whatever comes next.

What we didn’t do

We didn’t talk about our own everyday activities, for very good reasons. That would have required us to talk about ‘I’ and ‘us’ and ‘you’ and ‘we’ introducing many conjugations, and would have required all sorts of vocabulary – because everyone’s day is different – and would have been much harder to ‘attach’ to a shared image that gave us all the meaning.

Of course, we’ll expand into this soon, but while we’re taking our first steps in this part of the language it would have set us an impossible task: juggling lots of vocabulary, too many conjugations, too many contrasts and too many meanings that are hard for the whole class to share. Giving students tasks like this that are too far beyond their level is one of the reasons they lose confidence and find language classes frustrating.

What have we all been doing recently?

In this update on our Catalan project you’ll see how we are using the Class Conversation technique to grow our skills in talking about the everyday. And our progress really is snowballing as a result.

We’ve just had our 29ᵗʰ Catalan lesson. We happened to talk about what we’d all been doing recently. Watch the video to see the kinds of things we worked on.

The advantages of this kind of Class Conversation lesson with a group of intermediate students like we are are many. For example:

  • there’s never any shortage of things to talk about and things to find out about each other: every day is always different and everyone’s days are always different.
  • there’s always scope for practice – retelling the story from other perspectives, combining sentences into more complex ones, adding or omitting details
  • talking about the everyday automatically means we work on the common words and common structures: exactly our priorities at the moment
  • the lesson is entirely about our stories, not something the teacher or textbook author imposed. So we’re invested in the work and what our classmates have to say
  • everything gets worked on until it is correct, sentence-by-sentence, and immediately. That’s how we improve. And because every sentence is practised – ie said several times – the language gets properly lodged in our minds
  • nothing is written down, so we have to use our minds all the time – to construct each sentence each time; to listen properly to each other; and to construct our replies, or follow up questions; or to change the subject when we feel like it!

Even quite low intermediate level students can handle and enjoy this kind of conversation-based lesson. And don’t underestimate older students – the average age of this group of students is in the early seventies.

Our progress

We moved into this kind of lesson about a month ago after 25 hours of learning Catalan. And, as a quick look at the last few blogs in this series will illustrate, our progress is snowballing fast. This is typical of a Silent Way course: in the early stages we work on the fundamentals thoroughly with Cuisenaire rods and objects in the classroom, and then we move into students exploring their own and each other’s everyday lives through the language. What remains constant is that everything is worked on until it’s correct and has been practised. This is what enables us to speak confidently and accurately and make this kind of progress. And we have a lot of fun learning.

If you’d like to find out more, just message me or comment below.