Here’s the ‘pronunciometer’:

It’s simple: 10/10 means native-like, around 5 means kind of OK, and 1/10 means awful. It gives teachers a way to give students feedback in a precise, non-judgmental way about that all-important aspect of speaking a language: pronunciation.
Here’s how we used it in our Catalan lesson:
The purpose of having some kind of scale against which to judge our pronunciation is to remind us, we’re all aiming to get our students’ pronunciation as good as possible: as close as possible to native-like. And to give us an impetus to change something about how we say a word or phrase.
Put it another way, we, as students, really, really don’t want to end up around 4 or 5 on the scale – comprehensible but still sounding very ‘English’. That’d be awful and embarrassing. So, working word by word to improve from mediocre to better to good is what we want to do.
The scale on its own is of no value. The teacher has to follow it up with guidance on what the student needs to do to improve: where the flaws are in the student’s attempt, what to work on, where the energy balance between the syllables needs to be adjusted etc.
This is best done by directing the student’s attention to whatever changes they need to make to what they are doing with their voice and their muscles. And once the student has made an improvement, getting them to practice: ie say the word again a few times.
We’ll be using this tool in our future lessons to improve how we sound. And to build really good pronunciation skills.
I love the idea of the pronunciometer! I’ll definitely be adopting it.
One of the nice things that I see in it, it’s that it gives the possibility for students to decide whether they are OK with an 8 or 9 for example, or if they want to keep trying and aim for a 10.
I love the question “What do I need to do to make it 9?”!!!
I think even native speakers with no experience in teaching languages would become more aware of pronunciation issues in general by using this scale and by being asked this sort of question “What do I need to do…”. Oftentimes, native speakers just say things like “it’s a bit off”, “we can understand you, it’s fine”… but your question elicits precise feedback, which is exactly what learners need to improve their pronunciation.
Vítor! It’s fun isn’t it! I actually hadn’t thought of your idea, though … I guess I’m the sort of person that getting 6/10 is always going to motivate me to try for 7/10 etc etc etc … which as you say in your next comment, immediately leads to the question ‘What do I need to do to make it better?’
I’m that sort of person too! I almost always aim for a 10 when I’m learning a language ^^ (even if I know it may take a longer time than I wanted…)