Why taking notes in a language class is a bad idea

Taking notes in a language class is a bad idea. It is a distraction and it doesn’t store what you are supposed to be learning where it should be stored – in your mind

The work to learn a new language needs to happen in students’ minds: it’s here that new mental connections need to be made, meanings stored and new implicit criteria built.

Written notes may seem to have some permanence, but they aren’t where you need them to be—in your mind. And teachers sometimes encourage students to take notes so they ‘have something to refer to’ later.

This is a mistake. Teachers are better working in such a way that students start to develop knowledge and skills in their minds directly, there and then in the classroom. And if students forget some of what they worked on in previous lessons, that is simply a sign they need more exposure and more practice with these things until they become familiar and automatic.

Note-taking is a distraction

‘For optimal learning, the brain must avoid any distraction.’ (Dehaene, 2020, p162)

If students are taking notes in class then their attention is divided and they are distracted by the task of writing from what the teacher is trying to get them to work on—so the opportunity to learn directly from experiencing the language in class is lost

Re-reading notes v Free recall

Students can start to feel that their notes ARE their learning – and therefore that learning can somehow be outsourced to a notebook, computer, phone or flash cards. Rather than taking notes with the idea of re-reading them to somehow strengthen recall, students are much better giving the lesson their full attention.

After their lessons, ideally after they have slept or had a nap, students can say over—or even say, write and draw—whatever they happen to recall. This is a far more effective way of lodging a lesson in their minds. Teachers should encourage students to do this kind of ‘free recall’ practice.

And the easiest way for teachers to discourage note-taking is simply to remove students’ notebooks. Here’s how to do it without fuss or making it an issue (see video).

Dehaene, S. (2020). How we learn: The new science of education and the brain. London: Penguin Books.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *