Here’s some more analysis of the progress of our Catalan lessons. Our focus is gaining an intuitive grasp of the grammar of the language, through working on its functional vocabulary.
We’re doing this by our teachers making us aware of the connection between the visible meanings we see playing out in our shared online classroom and the language required to talk about them. And we’re taking one tiny step at a time, with each step getting practised and integrated with what went before. And this is all accumulating surprisingly rapidly.
We checked our progress against the syllabus for a typical communicative course set out in a standard textbook, looking at what that course covers in the same amout of time as we’ve spent. Of course there are things that that course covers that ours hasn’t (eg many social greetings, and things like ‘I speak language x and y’ etc), but these are more than balanced out by the things we’ve learnt that that course doesn’t include.
More importantly, as you can see in the video which follows, we can freely use everything we’ve learnt to say long, correct and accurate sentences. There is none of that hesitant, unwillingness to talk that so often results from textbook learning.
So its down to priorities: we’re laying down the basis for long term confidence in speaking the language well. And we’re having a lot of fun doing so. Personally, I wouldn’t do it any other way.
Two radically different ways of thinking about learning a language, one of which has science behind it, and one which doesn’t. Guess which is which…