The hypotheses proposed by Stephen Krashen imply that learning a foreign language is a subconscious process resulting from exposure to the language, and that explicit instruction in grammar doesn’t have much effect.
So far, so good.
But Dr Krashen also argues that ‘production’ ie speaking and writing should wait until we have acquired enough of the language. And that all that is required to acquire a language is sufficient exposure to enough ‘comprehensible input’ (by ‘input’ he means listening and reading). And, even better, if that input is ‘compelling’ as well as ‘comprehensible’. In fact, ideally, so compelling that the student forgets they are listening or reading in a foreign language.
Actually, this makes sense when you are reasonably advanced in a language. At that stage it is indeed possible to ‘pick up’ more language from any encounter with the language. Indeed we do exactly this all the time, even in our native language: a few years back ‘cool’ simply meant that something had a low temperature, but now all English speakers know that the word also has another meaning. No one taught us this, did they?
But what about beginners?
Right at the beginning of learning a language, when the student knows nothing, how are teachers supposed to provide ‘comprehensible input’? And what is the student supposed to do? Simply sit and passively listen?
In a Silent Way classroom we use Cuisenaire rods and other objects to show the class situations that we then coach the students to talk about. The meaning is obvious from what everyone can see, and the teacher works with the students, giving them the new things they need, until the sentences they say are correct, accurate and as well pronounced as possible.
This means everything is comprehensible, we can avoid translation, we can avoid grammar explanations, and the students are active. It is possible to work on almost every aspect of the language in this way. And, once the students have the basics of the language, we move on to coaching the students to talk about their lives; where, of course, they already know the meaning of what they want to talk about.
A different way of thinking about language
In fact, this suggests a different way of thinking about learning a foreign language.
The words ‘comprehensible input’ suggest that meaning lies in the words and the student’s job is to extract meaning from what someone else has said or written … whereas meaning really lies in the situations people talk about.
Our job as teachers is to give the student the ability to express the meaning that they perceive, in the words of a foreign language. And, of course, once someone knows how to express their intent accurately in a foreign language, they stand a chance of understanding what other people say to them.
So, until people are reasonably advanced in a language, I’m not sure ‘input’ has that much to do with the process of learning.
If you want to see how this works out in practice check out my video series Learning Japanese with the Silent Way.
For sure, what a beginner student says in a SW classroom is “comprehensible” input for the rest of the class because they all know what he’s going to say before he says it, or at least what they see is enough to understand what he says.
And in the case of the class conversation, it’s a bit more advanced, but the mechanics are similar. This time, the rest of the classroom doesn’t understand what the student is saying because it’s tangible or visible: in fact, many times they don’t really know what he’s talking about until he says it (eg: what did you do yesterday?). They understand what he’s saying because they’re roughly at the same level as he is, which means the content of the class conversation is at everyone’s reach.
In the end, I think you’re right to underline that Krashen’s model has little to do with the complex mechanics of the Silent Way. The Silent Way class is of course mostly about the awarenesses of the student trying to piece together his sentence at the limit of what he knows and what he’s still learning. The fact that clear/comprehensible output is produced all the time during the SW class, which becomes comprehensible input for the other students, might play a role also, but it’s mostly a by-product of the main process, which is: students saying stuff all lesson long.