Why I hate ‘gap-filling’ exercises

‘Filling in the gaps’ exercises are incredibly common. Here’s just one example: one of my a Spanish text books has a page with some exercises headed: ‘Utiliza el Pretérito Pluscuamperfecto de Subjuntivo en las siguientes frases’

‘Filling in the gaps’ exercises are incredibly common. Here’s just one example: one of my a Spanish text books has a page with some exercises headed:

‘Utiliza el Pretérito Pluscuamperfecto de Subjuntivo en las siguientes frases’

Followed by fourteen or so sentences like:

Me parecía raro que (ver, ellos) __________ a Jaime por el parque.

The student is meant to work out the form of the verb required and slot it into the gap, and then proceed onto the next example.

But, why would a teacher use these exercises?

What is the educational theory that this type of exercise is based on? And how do students actually react to this?

A ‘good’ student, presumably will work through each example diligently applying the rules which are laid out in a previous page in the book. But the whole exercise is so disjointed and boring that it’s almost impossible to do anything other than get through the exercise completely mechanically, and as quickly as possible.

If you try and do anything else, eg interpret its meaning, then you’re likely to go crazy, because sentence 1 starts talking about a visit to the theatre, sentence 2 sounds like a teacher telling students they can go when they’ve finished their exercises. By sentence 5, we’re discovering that it’s strange that there’s no one at home yet. Sentence 6 expresses a worry about the air-conditioning. By sentence 7, there’s been an accident. Sentence 9 is a warning to take care when cooking otherwise you’ll mess up your clothes. And so it goes on until sentence 12, when we’re commenting on how odd it is to see Jaime in the park.

There is no rhyme nor reason to this. Nor is there intended to be – and it isn’t even a Dadaist poem. But how is the student supposed to react to this ragbag of ideas and situations in any human or coherent way? How can anyone be interested in it?

No, but really, why would a teacher use these exercises?

Now if you start from the perspective that students need to practice a particular grammatical structure you’re almost certain to come up with something as mental as this, especially when your working with something like the ‘Pretérito Pluscuamperfecto de Subjuntivo’.

In fact treating this verb form (or any verb form for that matter) in this way is a real shame. This structure is one of the many wonders of the Spanish verb system that should be savoured and relished – on the fairly rare occasions that it comes up – for the psychological condition that it is used to evoke.

I can only speculate on what educational rationale a teacher might have for ever using this type of gap-filling exercise. Presumably, the theory is that students need to practice the mechanics of verb forms and they’d better knuckle down and slog through it? And the exercise is easy to mark and show students what they got wrong …

If this is the reason, then I have so many problems with it.

Firstly, as a student, this kind of thing means I will certainly be absent as much as possible, even if I am physically in the classroom. At best I will be disruptive and try to come up with as perverse as possible interpretation of the exercise … and then I’ll start playing up, asking impertinent questions and clock-watching till the end of class etc etc.

The whole chain of language

Secondly, as a teacher, it cannot be right to try to teach grammatical mechanics outwith the context of something meaningful being expressed.

The whole chain from meaning => words and grammar => vocalised syllables (or written letters) needs to be complete. Sure, it may make sense to temporarily isolate an element of a sentence a student is trying to say and work on that and then put it back in the context of the whole, now much improved, utterance.

But an incoherent set of mechanical exercises like this, even if they don’t actually send the students crazy, just leaves students with the message that meaning, and, in fact, in this case, shades of meaning, are not important and that mechanical manipulation is the route to success.

And, I would argue that unless the chain of language from meaning right through to sound (or letters) is complete then we aren’t really teaching people to speak or use a language. In this case, all we are actually teaching is ‘how to do (almost meaningless) boring “filling in the gaps” exercises’.

It can’t be emphasised sufficiently: anytime students are not working in the context of the whole chain that leads from meaning to sounds they’re not working on how to speak or use the language.

Work on the real thing

Wouldn’t it be better for us to work on the real thing? Start from whatever students actually want to say about their perceptions, experiences, ideas or feelings and help them find the language to say it.

It might be argued that there’s a danger the students might never come up with a situation that needs the ‘Pretérito Pluscuamperfecto de Subjuntivo’. And, of course, this is possibly true, but then equally, if they don’t need this structure to say what they want and need to say, then why ram it down their throats?

And in my experience, as students gradually expand their mastery of parts of the language, they find themselves naturally needing some of the less common aspects of the language. And at the stage that these parts of the language are actually needed, they’re much easier for the students to work on because, by then, all the rest of how the language ‘works’ is already established.

Eliminate gap-filling exercises

So, my advice is: eliminate these gap-filling exercises entirely from the classroom and find a way of working that starts from what students want and need to say. All that’s needed is to ask them a question and then work to perfect whatever answer they give.

And there are ways to manage the classroom time just as productively, in fact more so, than with these type of exercises.

Otherwise, the truth is, we’re not really teaching the language, we’re teaching something else.

A quotation to ponder

In conclusion, I was delighted the other day when a colleague shared this quote with me:

It can’t be said too often: we get better at using words, whether hearing, speaking, reading, or writing, under one condition and only one—when we use those words to say something we want to say, to people we want to say it to, for purposes that are our own.

Holt, J. (1967) How Children Learn, London: Penguin.

One thought on “Why I hate ‘gap-filling’ exercises”

  1. How right you are, Laurence! I
    love the quote from John Holt! He always has intelligent things to say about learning, I find.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *